Top view of business people working together at a conference table

Employees vs. Independent Contractors Following Enactment of AB5

Law Offices of Charles P. Boylston  Dec. 7, 2023

In the dynamic world of employment law, California's Assembly Bill 5 (AB5) has emerged as a game-changer. This ground-breaking legislation, enacted on January 1, 2020, was designed to correct the misclassification of over one million workers in the state who were previously labeled as independent contractors. AB5 introduced a stringent classification system known as the "ABC test," which determines whether a worker is an employee or an independent contractor based on specific criteria. This shift in classification is crucial as it directly impacts a worker's entitlement to benefits such as minimum wage, overtime, paid sick time, and meal breaks, along with the ability to unionize. 

For many businesses and individuals, working through these changes can be challenging. That's where we at the Law Offices of Charles P. Boylston step in. We're based in Temecula, California, and serve clients throughout Southern California, including San Diego County, Riverside County, Orange County, and Los Angeles County. With over 15 years of experience in resolving workplace disputes related to employment law, we're here to help you understand and adapt to the implications of AB5. Whether you're an employee seeking clarity about your rights under this new law or an employer needing guidance on compliance, we're committed to assisting you every step of the way

A New Era of Worker Classification

Few pieces of legislation have stirred as much discussion and debate in employment law as Assembly Bill 5 (AB5). This law has revolutionized how we view and classify workers in California. It was born out of a need to address the widespread issue of worker misclassification—where workers are labeled as independent contractors, often denying them the protections and benefits they would receive as employees. 

AB5's mission is to ensure that all workers enjoy their rightful entitlements under employment law. It does this by implementing a strict classification system known as the "ABC test". This test is a three-pronged approach that determines whether a worker is an employee or an independent contractor based on certain criteria. To be considered an independent contractor, the worker must be free from the company's control and direction, perform work that is outside the usual course of the company's business, and be engaged in an independently established trade, occupation, or business. If they don't meet any one of these factors, they're classified as an employee. 

The Impact on the Gig Economy

Undoubtedly, the gig economy has felt the most significant impact of AB5. Companies like Uber, Lyft, and DoorDash, which operate primarily with independent contractors, have been thrust into the spotlight. They argue that their drivers have the independence to decide when and where they work, and therefore should be classified as independent contractors. However, critics believe that these companies are circumventing the law to avoid providing benefits and protections such as minimum wage, overtime pay, and workers' compensation. 

This tension has sparked a broader debate about the pros and cons of being classified as an employee. Supporters of AB5 believe it offers crucial protections for workers, giving them access to benefits like healthcare, paid sick leave, and unemployment insurance. They argue that classifying workers as employees promotes job stability and economic security. Conversely, opponents of AB5 say it limits the flexibility and independence of workers, especially those in the gig economy who value the freedom that comes with being an independent contractor. 

Navigating AB5's Exemptions and Legal Challenges

In the wake of AB5's implementation, there have been numerous calls to amend or repeal the law. Various industries and worker groups are advocating for exemptions or modifications to the ABC test to accommodate certain professions or industries' unique characteristics. This has led to some exemptions being granted for specific healthcare professionals, freelance writers, and photographers, among others. 

However, non-compliance with AB5 can lead to severe consequences. Legal action can be taken by governmental entities or the workers themselves. Violations fall under the California Labor Code, allowing aggrieved workers to file lawsuits for lost pay and benefits. Moreover, if a worker is reclassified as an employee, the employer may be liable for any past taxes due under employee status. Willful misclassification can result in civil penalties ranging from $5,000 to $25,000 per violation. 

Looking Forward: The Future of AB5

The future of AB5 and its implications for worker classification in California remain uncertain. Balancing worker rights and employer interests in the fast-paced world of work is complex and nuanced. However, what is clear is that AB5 has brought about significant changes to the classification of workers in California. It has sparked debates and legal challenges, particularly in industries heavily reliant on independent contractors. 

At the Law Offices of Charles P. Boylston, we understand the ins and outs of employment law and the impact it can have on both businesses and individuals. We're committed to providing our clients in Southern California with the most up-to-date and relevant information to help them make informed decisions. If you have questions or concerns about AB5 and how it may affect you, don't hesitate to reach out to us. Our team is always ready to help.